Welsh Conservatives Debate - A&E department performance data
The Welsh Conservatives, led by Darren Millar, asked the Welsh Government to publish emergency department figures before exemptions, explain differences in data, and commission an independent review. Labour and Plaid Cymru tabled amendments. The Senedd rejected the motion as written; the votes listed show no outcome on the amendments.
Vote on the Welsh Conservative motion exactly as written, with none of the Labour or Plaid Cymru amendments added.
Rejected
For 14Against 38
Welsh Conservatives Debate
The Welsh Conservatives, led by Darren Millar, asked the Welsh Government to publish emergency department waiting figures before exemptions, explain differences in data, and commission an independent review. Labour and Plaid Cymru amendments were all rejected on tied votes. No vote on the motion itself is listed.
Labour's Lesley Griffiths proposed replacing most of the motion with wording noting health board assurances, the statistics regulator's welcome of Welsh Government steps, comparability with England, and ongoing review work.
Plaid Cymru's Heledd Fychan proposed adding points on the breach exemptions policy: most surveyed senior doctors view it negatively, waiting times have worsened, and it hampers resource planning.
Plaid Cymru's Heledd Fychan proposed replacing the call for an explanation of data differences with a call to scrap the breach exemptions policy, as the Royal College of Emergency Medicine wants.
Plaid Cymru Debate. Transport for Wales
Plaid Cymru's Heledd Fychan asked the Senedd to regret poor Transport for Wales rail punctuality, slow new train rollout and low satisfaction, and to call on the Welsh Government to act. Labour and the Conservatives tabled amendments. The only vote listed was on the original motion, and it was rejected.
Whether to agree Plaid Cymru's motion as written, with no changes from Labour's or the Conservatives' amendments.
Rejected
For 26Against 26
Plaid Cymru Debate
Plaid Cymru's Heledd Fychan brought a motion regretting poor Transport for Wales rail punctuality, old trains and low satisfaction, and asking the Government to fix them. Labour proposed replacing the criticism with praise for progress. The Conservatives proposed publishing the business case for £125 million extra funding. Both amendments were rejected on tied votes, so no changes were made.
Labour amendment: replace the motion's criticism and call for action with wording welcoming improved performance and investment, and the plan for new trains on 95 per cent of journeys by 2024.
Conservative amendment: add a call on the Welsh Government to publish Transport for Wales's business case for the extra £125 million of funding this year.
Rejected
How these votes work: the Senedd first votes on the motion as written. If that fails, it votes on each amendment in turn, then on the motion with any agreed changes.
Explanations are written by AI from the published motion and the debate. Check the wording on the vote's page before quoting.