Plenary
- Started
- 13:30
- Contributions
- 197
- Words spoken
- 34,518
Summary
The Senedd met in Plenary for questions to the First Minister, the business statement, and statements on local government, housing and planning, on social justice and equality, and on key infrastructure resilience. Members questioned Ministers on safeguarding, tax, housing, child poverty and the Menai bridge and M4. The meeting ended with Ministers setting out priorities and promising further statements and consultations.
Themes
- Housing, homelessness and renters' protections
- Child poverty and childcare
- Safeguarding and public services
- Tax and the cost of living
- Transport, energy and land use
1. Questions to the First Minister
The First Minister answered questions on safeguarding in schools, tax, high streets, roads, homelessness, energy, cladding, planning and childcare. In the party leaders' session he was pressed on Tata Steel, nursing jobs, Betsi Cadwaladr, badger culling, school support staff and solar farms.
- Andrew Griffin (Reform UK) asked the First Minister to commission or support an independent review of Gwynedd council's handling of the Neil Foden case. Rhun ap Iorwerth (Plaid Cymru) said he had been minded to pursue a further inquiry but the independent chair of the child practice review advised it would not add value. He pointed to action on safeguarding culture, accountability and children's voices, and said a review of section 5 of the report would be launched very soon.
- Lynne Neagle (Welsh Labour) asked the First Minister to commit to every recommendation of the 'Our Bravery Brought Justice' report and to keep the ministerial assurance board with Cyngor Gwynedd. Rhun ap Iorwerth said he wanted to give those assurances and to build on the earlier work.
- Benjamin Hodge Mckenna (Reform UK) asked the First Minister to confirm no new or existing taxes would rise this term. Rhun ap Iorwerth said there would be no change to income tax rates and that he wanted fair taxation. Peter Fox (Welsh Conservatives) asked about reviewing land transaction tax and business rates, and the First Minister said both would be reviewed. John Clark (Reform UK) asked for the tourism tax to be scrapped, and the First Minister said it would not be.
- Dan Thomas (Reform UK) asked about the First Minister's engagement with Tata's chief executive over the delayed electric arc furnace. Rhun ap Iorwerth said his Minister for Enterprise, Connectivity and Energy spoke to Tata Steel UK's chief executive yesterday about the electricity connection. He said many of the powers lie with the UK Government.
2. Business Statement and Announcement
The Trefnydd announced one addition to the agenda, a statement on key infrastructure resilience. Members then asked for statements on a range of issues, and the Trefnydd mostly pointed them to other routes for raising them.
- Llŷr Powell (Reform UK) asked for an update on the suicide prevention strategy and on male suicide rates. Heledd Fychan (Plaid Cymru), the Trefnydd, said she would discuss a written or oral statement with the relevant Ministers.
- Paul Davies (Welsh Conservatives) asked for a statement on whether the Welsh Government would intervene to safeguard services at Withybush and Bronglais hospitals. Heledd Fychan pointed to the Cabinet Minister's priorities statement of the previous week and encouraged continued engagement with him.
- James Evans (Reform UK) asked for a written statement with a timetable on waiting list eradication. Heledd Fychan said the work was in train, regular updates would follow, and the Government was not afraid of scrutiny.
- Sarah Cooper-Lesadd (Reform UK) asked for a statement on newly qualified midwives who have no posts to move into. Heledd Fychan said a workforce summit would be held very soon, after which the Cabinet Minister would update the Senedd.
3. Statement by the Cabinet Minister for Local Government, Housing and Planning: Priorities for Local Government, Housing and Planning
Siân Gwenllian set out her priorities for local government, housing and planning, centred on social housing supply, renters' rights and energy efficiency. Members questioned her on the new body Unnos, local government funding and renters' protections.
- Siân Gwenllian (Plaid Cymru) said her aim was 20,000 new social homes by 2030, with a new national development body, Unnos, to speed up supply. She also said she would bring forward proposals to legislate for a right to adequate housing and a package of measures to protect renters and set fair rents.
- Francesca O'Brien (Reform UK) said annual housebuilding falls well short of the 7,400 homes a year the Home Builders Federation says are needed. She called Unnos potentially another quango and said the planning system should be fixed first. Siân Gwenllian replied by citing 10,509 people, including 2,267 children, in temporary accommodation, and said an arm's-length body would allow long-term planning and funding.
- Jayne Bryant (Welsh Labour) asked whether work on the local government funding formula would continue and how Unnos would be measured. Siân Gwenllian said the Government was looking at reform of the formula, building on earlier work, and said £112.8 million extra had been secured for local government this year. She said she was convinced an arm's-length body was needed.
- Peter Fox (Welsh Conservatives) asked why the 20,000 homes target would be met when the previous Government missed its target, and described Unnos as another quango. Siân Gwenllian said the Government was starting from a better position, with homes already in the pipeline, and would look at innovative funding models. She said she would not compel local government and wanted a partnership.
4. Statement by the Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Minister for Social Justice and Equality: Priorities for Social Justice and Equality
Sioned Williams, Deputy First Minister, set out priorities on child poverty, childcare, the Cynnal child payment and equality. Opposition Members questioned costings, timescales and the Government's approach to the Supreme Court ruling on the Equality Act.
- Sioned Williams (Plaid Cymru) said reducing child poverty is at the core of the Government's work. She said the universal childcare offer would be the most generous in the UK at full roll-out. She announced that Steffan Evans of the Bevan Foundation would co-chair an expert group designing the Cynnal pilot payment.
- Helen Jenner (Reform UK) said the statement gave little on the cost, funding or delivery date of the childcare offer. Sioned Williams said costs would be developed through the expert group, the policy could be afforded within the Government's budget, and the Senedd would be able to scrutinise funding decisions.
- Lynne Neagle (Welsh Labour) asked about the timescale for the Cynnal payment and about representations to the UK Government. Sioned Williams said the Government was committed to introducing it as quickly as possible, was working at pace, and would give the Senedd further updates.
- Peter Fox (Welsh Conservatives) said people want delivery rather than more strategies and pilots, and raised the EHRC code and the Supreme Court ruling. Sioned Williams said the Government respects the Supreme Court decision and is looking at its effect on devolved policy. She said trans people remain protected by the Equality Act 2010 and the Government would stand up to transphobia.
5. Statement by the Deputy Minister for Transport: Key Infrastructure Resilience
Mark Hooper, Deputy Minister for Transport, updated the Senedd on closures of the Menai suspension bridge and on the M4 corridor. Members pressed him on the black route, the scope of the statement and funding.
- Mark Hooper (Plaid Cymru) said the Menai bridge had closed repeatedly because drivers ignored the 7.5 tonne limit. He said works were expected to finish in spring 2027, and enforcement with North Wales Police and the Driver and Vehicle Standards Agency was increasing. He told Mair Rowlands (Plaid Cymru) that closing the bridge may be the only safe option if breaches continue.
- Mark Hooper said the black route for the M4 was not credible and was off the table, citing the Gwent Levels and its long timescale. Paul Rock (Wales Green Party) welcomed this. Darren Millar (Welsh Conservatives) argued the black route was the fast-track option and should be looked at with environmental mitigation.
- Jayne Bryant (Welsh Labour) and Jason O'Connell (Reform UK) asked for detail on M4 options, junction closures and widening the A55. Mark Hooper said all road options except the black route remain in scope, some junction closures may be needed, and he would report back to Members in the autumn.